Barstool Pizza Review – Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria (Caldwell, NJ)

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a true gem located in Caldwell that is sure to satisfy your cravings for a delicious meal. The restaurant has been family-owned for generations and is known for its classic Italian dishes and mouth-watering pizzas that are loved by locals and visitors alike. Whether you are in the mood for classic spaghetti and meatballs or a fresh and tasty pizza with your favorite toppings, Angeloni’s has got you covered.

What sets Angeloni’s apart from other restaurants is its commitment to using only the freshest and finest ingredients in every dish they serve. From the hand-tossed dough of their pizzas to the juicy and tender meats in their Italian dishes, every bite is a testament to the passion and care that goes into every dish.

In addition to the fantastic food, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria also boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere. And that makes it the perfect place for a night out with family or friends, or even a romantic date. With its cozy decor, friendly staff, and inviting ambiance, Angeloni’s is a truly special place that you simply must experience.

So if you’re looking for a delicious meal in Caldwell, look no further than Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, this restaurant is sure to provide you with a meal you’ll never forget. So come on in and treat yourself to the best Italian food in town!

Angeloni Restaurant & Pizzeria

History of Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria has been a staple in Caldwell, NJ since 2012, providing the West Essex community with delicious Italian cuisine. Founded by the Conforti family, Nick Sr., Irma, Nick Jr., Mike, and Amanda, the restaurant has been a family-run business for four decades. Named after Irma’s grandmother, Philomena Angeloni from Italy, the restaurant has remained unchanged despite the changes in the area. Known for its classic “Thinny Thin” pizza, Angeloni’s is renowned for its authentic Italian specialties including pizzas, salads, pasta, and more. The Conforti family takes great pride in providing their customers with delectable and satisfying meals, always upholding their commitment to authenticity and quality.

Menu at Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

The menu at Angeloni’s is a true celebration of Italian cuisine. In fact, the extensive eight-page menu features a wide range of dishes that will tantalize your taste buds and satisfy even the most discerning of palates. Whether you’re in the mood for something savory or sweet, Angeloni’s has you covered. From the succulent hot capicola and soppressata sandwich to the mouth-watering chicken cutlet sandwich, there is something for everyone. Additionally, the restaurant takes great care to source only the freshest and highest quality ingredients, ensuring that every dish is bursting with flavor and nutrition.

The accolades for Angeloni’s are endless, with over 260 positive reviews from satisfied customers. This is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to providing the best quality food and service. Customers can be confident that they are getting the best when they dine at Angeloni’s.

For those who prefer to enjoy their meals in the comfort of their own homes, Angeloni’s provides convenient delivery services. Whether you’re in the mood for a delicious pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or a mouth-watering sandwich, Angeloni’s has you covered. You can sit back, relax, and savor the flavors of Italy in the comfort of your surroundings.


Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria has established a reputation as one of the best places to enjoy delicious and exceptional pizza. The restaurant takes pride in its commitment to using only the finest and freshest ingredients, combined with traditional cooking techniques, to produce pizzas that are truly exceptional in taste and texture. One dish that stands out on the menu filled with a variety of offerings is the “Thinny Thin” pizza. This thin-crust pizza is a work of art that is carefully crafted to deliver a crispy and flavorful experience with every bite. The crust is baked to perfection, ensuring a crispy texture, while the crown of golden cheese adds an extra touch of flavor and richness. This unique specialty pizza is a must-try for anyone who appreciates delicious food and an unforgettable dining experience.

Angeloni Restaurant & Pizzeria Pizza


Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is the ultimate destination for Italian cuisine lovers. Their extensive menu features an extensive selection of delicious pasta dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With classic favorites like spaghetti carbonara and fettuccine alfredo, their menu is sure to please anyone who loves traditional Italian cuisine. But if you’re looking for something a little more creative, Angeloni’s has you covered. Their innovative menu includes unique and inventive pasta dishes that are sure to impress even the most discerning of diners.

At Angeloni’s, they understand the importance of using only the freshest ingredients to create their dishes. Their chefs take great care in sourcing the best ingredients, ensuring that each dish is bursting with flavor and aroma. From the first bite to the last, you’ll be able to taste the quality that goes into every dish they prepare.



Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is renowned for its exceptional sandwiches that tantalize the taste buds of its customers. The restaurant offers a diverse range of sandwiches that cater to the varying tastes and preferences of its customers. Their cold sandwiches are the perfect choice for those who prefer a lighter meal and come with a variety of fresh ingredients including crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, sliced onions, and the restaurant’s signature house dressing. Moreover, these sandwiches are a delightful blend of flavor and nutrition and are sure to leave you feeling satisfied and refreshed.

For those who prefer a heartier meal, Angeloni’s also offers a range of hot sandwiches that are bursting with flavor. One of the most popular hot sandwiches on the menu is the Capicola and Sopressata Sandwich, which features slices of savory Capicola and Sopressata ham, melted mozzarella cheese, and is drizzled with a tangy balsamic glaze. Another hot sandwich that is sure to delight is the Chicken Cutlet Sandwich, which features a tender, juicy chicken cutlet that is breaded and fried to perfection, served on a soft Italian roll, and topped with melted mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.

Whether you’re in the mood for something cold or hot, Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria has something for everyone. With their delicious sandwiches and friendly service, it’s no wonder why so many customers choose to dine at Angeloni’s time and time again.

Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria Sandwiches

Soups and Salads

At Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Caldwell, diners can enjoy a selection of premium thin-crust pizzas, along with classic appetizers, soups, salads, sandwiches, and dinner options. The restaurant offers a delicious selection of soups made with fresh ingredients such as chicken, broth, noodles, and vegetables. Salads are served with their dressing unless specified. For over a decade, Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria has been a staple of the Caldwell community, providing its customers with a range of tasty dishes to enjoy.

Soups and Salads


At Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria in Caldwell, NJ, guests can indulge in a mouth-watering array of appetizers that are sure to tantalize their taste buds. Whether you’re in the mood for classic staples like Buffalo Wings or Chicken Cutlet Sandwich or looking to try something new and exciting, Angeloni’s has got you covered. Furthermore, one of their most popular items on the menu is Grandma Irma’s Pizza. It is a unique thin-crust Sicilian-style pizza that is a true work of art. Only the freshest and finest ingredients go into making this pizza, which is sure to satisfy even the most discerning of palates.


Seafood and Chicken

Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Caldwell offers a delicious selection of seafood and chicken dishes for their customers to enjoy. Their menu features a variety of grilled chicken dishes, including options like grilled chicken with vegetables, grilled chicken with garlic sauce, and more. They also offer an array of seafood options like shrimp scampi, fried calamari, and pan-seared tilapia. All the dishes are made with the freshest ingredients and served in a warm, family atmosphere. Moreover, guests can enjoy the restaurant’s Italian-inspired menu while being surrounded by the cozy ambiance of 6 Brookside Avenue in Caldwell, NJ. However, Angeloni’s Pizzeria & Restaurant provides an ideal destination for those looking to enjoy high-end dining in a comfortable environment.

Seafood and Chicken

The Atmosphere at Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria 

At Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Caldwell, NJ, customers can enjoy a refined Italian-inspired menu and a warm, family atmosphere. The hospitable staff dedicates themselves to providing enjoyable service and ensuring they give each customer an enjoyable experience. Angeloni’s offers high-end dining with a touch of home. Furthermore, diners can order food online or make reservations to ensure they get the best seat in the house. With its welcoming atmosphere and delicious menu, Angeloni’s is a great place to gather with family and friends.

The Service at Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

The staff service at Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Caldwell is always friendly and accommodating. Customers can expect a warm welcome and personalized attention when they visit the restaurant. The staff takes the time to get to know their customers, which makes them feel at home. As well as, the staff are knowledgeable about the menu and can assist in making recommendations based on individual tastes. They are attentive to customer needs and strive to make sure everyone has an enjoyable experience. Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is a family-run business and the staff ensures that everything is perfect for their guests each time they visit.

Layout and Decor

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment that has been serving up classic Italian cuisine for over 30 years. The restaurant has an inviting atmosphere with warm, wooden furniture and bright, contemporary decor. The Angeloni family originally framed Italian artwork and vintage photos to adorn the walls. Furthermore, the kitchen is open to the dining area, showcasing the talented chefs in action. As well as, there is plenty of seating available, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal or occasion. Moreover, the bar offers a wide selection of craft beers and wines, perfect for pairing with their famous pizzas. Angeloni’s also offers catering services for any event, large or small.

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Interior

Authentic Food Experience

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a family-run establishment that provides customers with an authentic and unforgettable Italian dining experience. The rich culinary heritage of Italy inspires the classic dishes that the restaurant prides itself on. Moreover, all of the ingredients used are fresh, ensuring that every dish is of the highest quality. From their signature pizzas to their homemade sauces and pasta, every dish is prepared with love and attention to detail, making sure that each meal is not just delicious. but also a celebration of the flavors of Italy. Whether you are seeking a casual lunch or an elegant dinner, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is the perfect place to enjoy a meal that will leave you satisfied and impressed. However, the staff takes great care in making sure that each customer’s dining experience is unforgettable and will leave you eager to return for more.

Customers Review

    1. A few of us went out for lunch. We got two thinny thin pizzas for an appetizer and they were great – tasty, light, and crisp with the extra cheese in the crust.
    2. We have been coming to Angeloni’s for years. Delicious authentic Italian cuisine. We love the thin-crust cheese pizza. Everything is so delicious.
    3. Good service and delicious pizzas with perfectly crispy and tasty thin crust! BYOB helps too. Their salads and other apps are also delicious.


Address: 6 Brookside Ave, Caldwell, NJ 07006, USA


Contact Details

Official Website:

Phone: +1 973-226-1234


Download in PDF

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What Type of Cuisine does Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Specialize in?

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria are renowned for their exceptional Italian cuisine. And they offer a wide range of pizza and other Italian dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

2. What is the Atmosphere of Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Like?

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a warm and inviting place with a professional yet relaxed atmosphere. Their staff is friendly and attentive, always willing to help with whatever you need. As well as, the decor is modern and comfortable, with a cozy atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot for a night out or an intimate family meal. Furthermore, the menu offers a variety of delicious Italian dishes, from classic pizzas to comforting pasta dishes. With its great service, inviting atmosphere, and delicious food, this restaurant is an excellent choice for your next dining experience.

3. Does Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria have a Bar?

No, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria do not have a bar.

4. Is there Outdoor Seating Available at Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria?

Yes, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria does offer outdoor seating for guests.

5. Do Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Offer Catering Services?

Yes, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria offer catering services. They provide a wide range of catering options to suit all events and budgets.

6. Are there Any Vegetarian Options Available at Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria?

Yes, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria offer a variety of vegetarian options on their menu. The restaurant offers a selection of vegetarian pizzas, salads, sandwiches, and pasta.

7. Does Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Offer Takeout or Delivery Services?

Yes, Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria offer takeout and delivery services.


Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a top-notch dining establishment that offers a unique and satisfying dining experience for anyone looking for a delicious taste of Italy. With its focus on traditional Italian cuisine and its commitment to using only the freshest and highest-quality ingredients. Furthermore, Angeloni’s serves up an impressive menu of mouth-watering dishes that are sure to impress. Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch with friends, a romantic dinner with your significant other, or a family gathering. Angeloni’s is the perfect place to indulge in some of the best Italian food around. However, if you’re a fan of Italian cuisine and are looking for a place to satisfy your cravings. So make sure to check out Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria today!

Enjoyed this video?
Angeloni Restaurant and Pizzeria
"No Thanks. Please Close This Box!"